• Contact Us
  • Advertisement
  • Login
Upgrade
Agogo Ayo News
Advertisement
  • Home
  • News
    • Nigeria
    • South Africa
  • Lifestyle
  • Business
  • Features
  • Culture
  • Religion
  • Video
  • Competitions
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • Nigeria
    • South Africa
  • Lifestyle
  • Business
  • Features
  • Culture
  • Religion
  • Video
  • Competitions
No Result
View All Result
Agogo Ayo News
No Result
View All Result
Home Lifestyle

South Africa’s Afrophobic Bill Discriminates against Non-Permanent Residence Permit Holders

Femi Oshin by Femi Oshin
October 9, 2020
in Lifestyle, News
South Africa’s Afrophobic Bill Discriminates against Non-Permanent Residence Permit Holders
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Gauteng’s Member of the Executive Council (MEC) for economic development published the Gauteng Township Economic Development Bill, which seeks, among other things, to reserve certain business activities in “designated townships” exclusively and solely for ownership and operation by citizens and permanent residents of South Africa.

However, observations revealed that section 7(2) of the bill does not only discriminate against all non-citizens. Instead, it discriminates against non-citizens who are not permanent residents. This includes not only undocumented immigrants but also documented immigrants (including immigrants married to a South African spouse) and refugees who have not yet acquired permanent residency status.

Herman Mashaba’s ActionSA and other anti-African immigrant groups often complain when they are called Afrophobic or xenophobic.

Meanwhile, their view that immigration is necessarily bad for South African citizens, and that the tightening of immigration rules and better enforcement will necessarily benefit South Africans is not being bought by many people.

Mashaba and his cliques argue that every country has immigration laws and they are that they only insist that these be tightened and better enforced for the benefit of South African citizens.

READ ALSO  Family begs hospital for release of son's corpse over N10m bill

Moreover, many people wonder why these anti-African foreigners closed their eyes and ears at all the academic studies that have found that immigrants in South Africa generate jobs for locals and that immigrants contribute substantially to the South African economy.

The Mashaba ‘WhatsApp Group’ say they “merely” support “orderly” immigration and other restrictions on (African) immigrants to enter, but eyebrows are raised on why their immigration snag is exclusively about African immigrants, which makes it look prejudicial.

In South Africa, African immigrants have been shame-labelled and accused of spreading “unknown diseases” and, in one infamous tweet by Mashaba, of bringing “us Ebola in the name of small business”.

It has been observed that anti-immigrant narratives tend to reinforce societal prejudices, serving as a “call to fight” for the violent groups.

A Congolse business man in Central Johannesburg said: “So what happens to someone who has a business permit in South Africa and does not have have a permanent residence. I suspect Mashaba is working for some white people who are bent on taking over businesses from Africans in South Africa”.

READ ALSO  Suspect Beaten to Death after body of Missing 9-yr-old girl was found in His Wardrobe

SECTION 7(2)
Furthermore, while section 7(2) of the bill clearly discriminates against categories of non-citizens, this alone will not render the section in breach of section 9(3) of the Constitution. Section 7(2) of the bill will only be in breach of section 9(3) of the Constitution if this “discrimination” is found to be “unfair”.

A court will weigh up all the relevant factors to determine whether the discrimination is unfair, and hence unconstitutional and invalid.

First, it will look at the “position of the complainants in society” and whether they have suffered in the past from patterns of disadvantage. It is easier to justify “discrimination” against a powerful group than against a vulnerable group.

As noted above, non-citizens (especially from the rest of the continent) are a vulnerable group, facing extreme prejudice and even physical harm. Regular eruptions of xenophobic violence (aimed at African immigrants, regardless of whether they are documented or not, and whether they are permanent residents or not), render African immigrants particularly vulnerable.

READ ALSO  German Church Gives Church Space To Muslim Worshippers To Allow Comply With Social Distancing Rule

Second, a court will look at the purpose sought to be achieved by the discriminatory provision. If the “discriminatory” provision is aimed at achieving a worthy and important societal goal, it would be easier to justify the discrimination. The stated purpose of section 7(2) – the development of vibrant township economies in Gauteng – appears to be worthy.

However, the manner in which section 7(2) is formulated suggests that the clause is also aimed at placating the fears and anger harboured by some voters towards immigrants from the rest of the continent.

This would not be a worthy purpose as the Constitutional Court (in Hoffmann v South African Airways) rejected the argument that discrimination can be justified to pander to the prejudices of the public, stating unequivocally: “Prejudice can never justify unfair discrimination.”

Tags: South Africa's 'Xenophobic Bill Discriminates Against Non-Permanent Residence Permit HoldersSouth Africa's Afrophobic Bill Discriminates against Non-Permanent Residence Permit Holders
Previous Post

UN Condemns Xenophobia as Nigerian Man Doused in Petrol & Burnt Alive by 3 Libyan Men

Next Post

Lagos State Cringed & Pardon Funke Akindele & Her Husband Seeing Its Case was Flawed – Lawyer

Femi Oshin

Femi Oshin

Related Posts

Actress Iyabo Ojo Hits Her Fans Hard on Toxic Relationships
Entertainment

Actress Iyabo Ojo Hits Her Fans Hard on Toxic Relationships

by Kanyin Oshin
January 20, 2021
Comedienne Princess Reveals Why Her Marriage Failed & Gives Golden Advice to Women
Entertainment

Comedienne Princess Reveals Why Her Marriage Failed & Gives Golden Advice to Women

by Kanyin Oshin
January 20, 2021
Ooni of Ife Rejected the Deities’ Warning That Queen Naomi Was a Serpentine Priestess
Entertainment

Ooni of Ife Rejected the Deities’ Warning That Queen Naomi Was a Serpentine Priestess

by Kanyin Oshin
January 18, 2021
20,063 South Africans Died in 1 Week; 10,907 Excess, Covid-19 is a suspected major cause
Lifestyle

20,063 South Africans Died in 1 Week; 10,907 Excess, Covid-19 is a suspected major cause

by Femi Oshin
January 14, 2021
Dr. Austin Ezeogu to be laid to rest on Friday
News

Dr. Austin Ezeogu to be laid to rest on Friday

by Agogo Ayo News
January 12, 2021
Next Post
Lagos State Cringed & Pardon Funke Akindele & Her Husband Seeing Its Case was Flawed – Lawyer

Lagos State Cringed & Pardon Funke Akindele & Her Husband Seeing Its Case was Flawed - Lawyer

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest News

Actress Iyabo Ojo Hits Her Fans Hard on Toxic Relationships

Actress Iyabo Ojo Hits Her Fans Hard on Toxic Relationships

January 20, 2021
Comedienne Princess Reveals Why Her Marriage Failed & Gives Golden Advice to Women

Comedienne Princess Reveals Why Her Marriage Failed & Gives Golden Advice to Women

January 20, 2021
Ooni of Ife Rejected the Deities’ Warning That Queen Naomi Was a Serpentine Priestess

Ooni of Ife Rejected the Deities’ Warning That Queen Naomi Was a Serpentine Priestess

January 18, 2021
20,063 South Africans Died in 1 Week; 10,907 Excess, Covid-19 is a suspected major cause

20,063 South Africans Died in 1 Week; 10,907 Excess, Covid-19 is a suspected major cause

January 14, 2021
Dr. Austin Ezeogu to be laid to rest on Friday

Dr. Austin Ezeogu to be laid to rest on Friday

January 12, 2021
Original Owner of “Odun Nlo Sopin” – Evergreen Yoruba December Song Revealed

Original Owner of “Odun Nlo Sopin” – Evergreen Yoruba December Song Revealed

January 3, 2021
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Agogo Ayo News

Agogo Ayo News is Africa's leading news platform based in Johannesburg, South Africa

Recent Posts

  • Actress Iyabo Ojo Hits Her Fans Hard on Toxic Relationships
  • Comedienne Princess Reveals Why Her Marriage Failed & Gives Golden Advice to Women
  • Ooni of Ife Rejected the Deities’ Warning That Queen Naomi Was a Serpentine Priestess
  • 20,063 South Africans Died in 1 Week; 10,907 Excess, Covid-19 is a suspected major cause
  • Dr. Austin Ezeogu to be laid to rest on Friday

© 2020 Agogo Ayo News - Powered by Better Africa Communications.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • Nigeria
    • South Africa
  • Lifestyle
  • Business
  • Features
  • Culture
  • Religion
  • Video
  • Competitions

© 2020 Agogo Ayo News - Powered by Better Africa Communications.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?